top cx logo
cx logo
Explorearrow down
search icon

‘Should unvaccinated pay for care?’ asks head of Paris hospital group

The hospital boss raised the ‘delicate’ question about ‘consequences for not taking a free preventative measure’ yesterday, prompting backlash from some politicians

The hospital director asked if people who are not vaccinated should be required to pay for their own Covid-19 medical treatment Pic: Deliris / Shutterstock

The head of major Paris hospital group AP-HP has hypothetically questioned if unvaccinated people in France should have to pay for their Covid-related medical care.

Martin Hirsch, director-general of Assistance Publique – Hôpitaux de Paris (AP-HP) – which comprises 39 Paris hospitals that treat more than 8.3 million patients per year – raised the issue on TV discussion show C à Vous on France 5 last night (Wednesday, January 26).

He said: “When a free, preventative measure is available, which can be used, which is recognised by the scientific community as something useful; and someone decides not to take it, can they really do that without there being any consequences?

“Or do we reach out to help, but we say there is no reason that there  wouldn’t  be consequences for them, when there will be [consequences] for other patients who we are struggling to care for, who can’t do anything about their condition.”

He added: “I don’t want to close the doors of the hospital to anyone, but we must encourage responsibility, which allows everyone to benefit.”

Mr Hirsch said he recognised how “delicate” the question was, and said the answer wasn’t “obvious”.

He said: “If we recognised the need for a testing system to be put in place every year, should we have access to the exact same protection and reimbursement if we don’t do it, as someone who does do it? 

“I don’t want spending on health to explode because of irresponsible behaviour that is compromising everyone else’s solidarity.” 

Backlash: ‘A philosophical question’

Mr Hirsch’s comments have provoked opposition from some.

Presidential election candidate Florian Philippot, right-wing leader of Les Patriotes party, said: “Martin Hirsch wants to make non-vaccinated people pay to continue receiving care! So we just let poor people die? In a normal country, this kind of guy would be sacked on the spot!”

Mr Philippot has also called Mr Hirsch’s comments “shameful” and later tweeted: “We ask all doctors who prefer the Hippocratic oath to the Pfizer oath, to recall loud and clear the principles of support and equality in health care!”

Mayor of Paris Anne Hidalgo, herself also a presidential candidate, has also come out against the suggestion.

She told BMFTV and RMC: “I am not in agreement with this kind of measure. We have defined a strategy, which is vaccination, and we have to increase and continue with it, because it protects.

“[Mr Hirsch’s idea] is a philosophical question that I would not resolve in this way. I think society is already too divided and we must bring people in France together.”

Related articles

French MPs deny Covid vaccine pass comes too late to make a difference 

‘Fully vaccinated’: does meaning vary in France depending on context?

Coronavirus: Daily updates on the situation in France

Resident or second-home owner in France?
Benefit from our daily digest of headlines and how-to's to help you make the most of life in France
By joining the newsletter, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy
See more popular articles
The Connexion Help Guides
featured helpguide
Income Tax in France 2023 (for 2022 income)*
Featured Help Guide
- Primarily aimed at Britons, covers pensions, rent, ISAs, shares, savings and interest - but also contains significant general information pertinent to readers of other nationalities - Overview of online declarations + step-by-step guide to the French printed forms - Includes updates given automatically after this year's site opened
Get news, views and information from France