magazine
Why cutting invasive plants can make them spread
Giant hogweed, Japanese knotweed and ragweed are spreading in France. Learn why cutting invasive plants can worsen the problem and how they are controlled
In Honfleur, gardeners have been fighting a giant invasive plant for years – but simply cutting it down is not necessarily the answer.
Giant hogweed (berce du Caucase) can grow several metres tall and its sap can cause severe burns when it comes into contact with exposed skin in sunlight.
Sébastien Dessaux, who has been responsible for Honfleur’s green spaces for 30 years, says the plant is tackled largely by hand, at a carefully chosen stage when it is beginning to flower but before its seeds become fertile.
The aim is to contain it rather than eradicate it.
“If we let it prosper, birds eat the seeds and spread them everywhere,” he says. Cutting it mechanically can also scatter seeds further afield.
Honfleur is far from alone in dealing with invasive species.
Since 2018, the Conservatoire d’espaces naturels de Normandie (CEN Normandie) has run a regional programme helping local authorities identify and manage them.
Jean-François Dufaux, who runs the programme, estimates there are around 1,300 invasive species in France, with around 12 new species becoming established in each department every ten years.
“It is a phenomenon that we cannot eradicate. It is the equivalent of a tsunami,” he says.
The consequences are not limited to biodiversity. Ambroisie à feuilles d’armoise – common ragweed – is particularly widespread in southern France. Its highly allergenic pollen affects an estimated five million people and Mr Dufaux puts the economic cost linked to sick leave at around €330 million a year.
Managing invasive plants incorrectly can also make matters worse.
Japanese knotweed (renouée du Japon), for example, is common along roadsides. Cutting it with machinery can break it into small pieces from which new plants develop. Mr Dufaux says a 100-metre patch can consequently stretch to 120 or 130 metres the following year.
Sometimes the correct response is therefore not to attack a plant immediately, but to cover it, encourage competing native vegetation or use carefully controlled cutting.
Some species present a more immediate danger.
Giant hogweed is found across Normandy, particularly in Calvados and Seine-Maritime. A related species, Sosnowsky’s hogweed (berce de Sosnovski), is subject to even stricter controls: since 2018, it has been illegal in France to possess, plant, cultivate, sell or deliberately release it into the environment.
Back in Honfleur, Mr Dessaux explains that completely removing giant hogweed would require major excavation.
One less drastic weapon has proved useful: goats.
Eco-grazing works because the animals repeatedly eat the plants, gradually exhausting them – another example of why fighting invasive species is often less about destroying them than knowing how to keep them under control.