news
Apple to stand trial in Paris over accusations of ‘planned obsolescence’
In a legal first, phone giant accused of making iPhones hard to repair outside official channels
US tech giant Apple will stand trial in France next year over allegations that its phones are manufactured with ‘planned obsolescence’ in mind.
The term ‘planned obsolescence’ refers to the practice of intentionally designing products to wear out or become outdated, forcing consumers to buy replacements, often only through proprietary channels.
The trial against Apple will reportedly take place in Paris in June 2027 and hinges on claims of ‘planned obsolescence’ in its iPhones.
The ‘Halte à l'obsolescence programmée’ association that filed the legal complaint against Apple called it a first trial of its type. The group originally filed its complaint in December 2022.
For its part, Apple categorically denied the charges and said “we firmly contest these unfounded allegations.”
If Apple is found guilty, it could be fined up to €300,000 – or a percentage of its annual revenue – as well as potentially face compensation claims from customers.
While this is the first trial of its kind, the association previously filed a complaint in 2017 accusing Apple of failing to inform users that software updates could slow down their devices.
In a settlement, Apple agreed to pay a €25 million fine, one of several such agreements following a number of complaints worldwide, as well as post a message on its website about the software updates for one month.
Customers forced into repairs or upgrades
The case has been called to trial by the Paris public prosecutor’s office, with Apple Distribution International and its parent company Apple Inc ordered to attend a four-day hearing beginning June 17, 2027.
The companies are accused of deliberately preventing repairs on a series of iPhone models between November 2021 and July 2024.
Several models are covered in this period, including the iPhone XS, the iPhone 12, 13, 14 and 15 series, as well as the iPhone SE.
This includes schemes to “make it impossible to repair or refurbish [the devices]... outside of its authorised channels,” the source said, with these ‘channels’ being official Apple stores and authorised repair points.
Engineers at Apple are suspected of configuring phone operating systems to “check the serial numbers of components,” and then disabling certain features if repaired or replaced outside of the official Apple network.
Examples include the ‘Face ID’ feature not working if repaired outside of an authorised shop, or the ‘battery health’ feature no longer functioning correctly.
The aim of the suspected changes was to increase revenue by forcing customers to either undergo repairs at Apple stores – where prices would be controlled by Apple – or otherwise require consumers to buy new phones, most likely in the Apple range because the customer would already be connected to several Apple-exclusive apps or phone services.