McDonald’s France defends charging €1.75 for ‘filtered’ tap water
The chain claims it reduces use of bottle water and thus plastic but critics question the legality of charging. We look at France’s bottled water use and how tap water costs compare within Europe
Restaurants in France must offer ‘ordinary water’ for free to customers who buy food Pic: Andrew Angelov / Shutterstock
McDonald’s in France has replaced bottled Evian water on its menus with an offer of fresh water from a drinking fountain, costing €1.75 for a 25cl glass or €2.30 for 50cl.
The fountain offers paying customers still, sparkling or flavoured Eau de McDo (Water by McDonald’s) with the chain saying it is a move towards reducing the use of plastic in its French restaurants.
In March 2021, the company announced it would stop selling drinks in plastic bottles in France - but the price for a glass of tap water has shocked customers and officials.
In a tweet, Parisian deputy mayor for water and president of Eau de Paris, Dan Lert calculated that the Parisian water from processing service Eau de Paris, which provides tap water in homes and numerous public drinking fountains, costs €0.003 per litre.
Voilà comment @McDonaldsFrance justifie de vendre de l'eau du robinet 2000 fois plus cher que son coût.— Dan Lert (@danlert) September 27, 2021
Breaking news : il est inutile de vouloir filtrer l'@eaudeparis qui est d'excellente qualité, sauf à vouloir éliminer le calcium et le magnésium utiles à notre corps. pic.twitter.com/GUoiFk5Pbi
In contrast, McDonald’s is charging €7 per litre of water in its restaurants, he said, a 2,000% markup.
In response, the restaurant chain said that the charge covered the “investment” in its restaurants in order to install the drinking fountain system, which provides “micro-filtered” water “purified at 99.99%”.
Critics have pointed out that McDonald’s is purifying French tap water that has already been treated, so it is safe for drinking, and is recognised as being good quality throughout France.
Can a restaurant in France legally charge customers for tap water?
Others have questioned the legality of charging for tap water, which is often provided for free by restaurants, cafes and bars.
But restaurants only have an obligation to provide free water in some circumstances.
A 1967 law stipulates that “ordinary water” should be included in the final cost of a meal for free, along with bread and cutlery.
And a 2020 law states that restaurants should “indicate in a visible way on the menu or a sign that customers can ask for free drinking water”.
However, the rules are different for cafes and bars that do not serve food.
Here, a customer ordering a coffee can legally be charged for a glass of water, as long as the price is clearly indicated on signs and menus.
In the same way, cafes and restaurants that serve food have the right to charge customers for water if they do not eat but order a coffee instead, for example.
This means that McDonald’s should still offer customers who eat in its restaurants “ordinary water”, as defined by the 1967 law, for free.
It is likely that the fast-food chain is able to charge for its Eau de McDo on the grounds that it has been processed and flavoured by the company.
How many people drink tap water as compared to bottled in France?
Tap water is safe to drink across the vast majority of France, but figures show that 75% of the population drinks both tap water and bottled.
This makes France one of the largest consumers of bottled water in Europe, with more than seven billion bottles sold every year.
A study cited by FranceInfo found that eight in 10 people believe that bottled water is better for health than tap water.
Journalist Justine Weyl said: “With 122 litres drunk per inhabitant, France is the fourth largest European consumer of bottled water, behind Italy, Germany, and Belgium.
“The bottled water industry [in France] is worth €2.8billion, and provides 10,000 direct jobs, and 30,000 indirect jobs.”
The top brands for still water in France are Cristaline, Vittel, Volvic, Evian, and Hépar, La Croix has reported.
Sparkling water (eau gazeuse or pétillante) is also popular, and in many restaurants, if you do not specify ‘eau plate’, you are likely to be served a sparkling bottle from one of the main French brands, such as Perrier, Badoit, Saint-Yorre, and La Salvetat.
Different brands make different assertions about the mineral content of their water, with the brand Taillefine claiming to help you lose weight; and some specifically saying they are ideal for use in babies’ bottles.
If ordering water in France, and you want to specify the kind from the tap, ask for a ‘carafe d’eau’ rather than a ‘bouteille’. Usually, this will be free, if ordered with food.
How does the price of water compare within Europe?
French costs for tap water compare relatively well with the rest of Europe, as neither the most expensive, nor the cheapest.
The Holidu water price index, using data from The International Benchmarking Network for Water and Sanitation Utilities (IBNET), compared the price of tap water in 114 cities globally.
In a study from early 2021, Oslo in Norway came out highest, at a price of €5.51 per 1,000 litres of drinking water (1m3).
Germany was also high on the list, with the cities Stuttgart (€4.67), Hamburg (€3.49), and Munich (€3.45) all in the top 10.
Denmark was also high, in Copenhagen (€4.37); while cities in the Netherlands and Sweden were also high (Rotterdam, €3.99; Amsterdam, €3.65; and Stockholm, €3.60).
In France, the city of Lyon is most expensive, at €3.57 per 1,000 litres, putting it at seventh-most expensive on the list. Paris is lower down, at 2.14 (number 21 on the ranking, out of 36 listed).
Some of the cheapest tap water can be found in Italy, Hungary and Greece, at €1.29, €1.05 and €0.40 per 1,000 litres in Naples, Rome, and Milan respectively; €1.23 in Budapest, and €1.16 in Athens.