driving

More French towns replace ‘priority to the right’ with stop signs

A low-cost alternative to roundabouts

The sign is intended to address excessive speeds and repeated accidents
Published

The stop sign trend is seeing a comeback in France, with more communes and cities introducing them at intersections they consider to be dangerous.

In recent months, communes in different parts of the country have been announcing new installations, often replacing what is called in France priorité à droite, where drivers must give way to vehicles approaching from their right.

In Juziers, Yvelines, the mairie said on November 13 that two new stop signs had been installed at the junctions of rue des Clos Collets and Square Baroche. They replace priority-to-the-right arrangements considered dangerous by the municipality.

In Montigny-le-Bretonneux, also in Yvelines, a municipal order announced a new stop sign on rue Louis-Antoine-de-Bougainville, at its junction with rue Paul-Émile-Victor. The decision was taken after residents complained about low visibility, caused by vegetation.

A similar measure was introduced in Neuville-Saint-Rémy, Nord. A municipal order dated October 20 introduced a stop sign at the exit of a cul-de-sac on rue du Verger.

Elsewhere, in Saint-Étienne-de-Tulmont, Tarn-et-Garonne, the municipality added two stop signs at the junction of chemin des Gamots and chemin de Pousiniès, bringing the total to four at the crossroads.

The decision was intended to address speeding and ongoing accidents. However, the unusual arrangement caused confusion, as drivers have to work out who should proceed first when several vehicles arrive at the junction at the same time.

Meanwhile, in Machecoul-Saint-Même, Loire-Atlantique, around 15 stop signs were installed within a few weeks to replace priorité à droite arrangements at intersections considered dangerous.

A cheaper way to improve road safety

One of the reasons communes are turning to stop signs to address excessive speed and road accidents is their low cost compared with larger infrastructure projects such as roundabouts.

Prices listed by French road-sign supplier Magequip range from €44 to €114 excluding VAT for an AB4 stop sign, depending on its size. This does not include the cost of installation.

“What causes accidents is speed. Reducing it, and in this case, stopping traffic, reduces both the number and severity of accidents,” Sophy Sainten, general delegate of road safety association Prévention Routière, told TF1.

Not everyone is on the same page

However, the increased use of stop signs is not welcomed by everyone.

Some residents have questioned the removal of priorité à droite, saying that the rule itself encouraged motorists to slow down when approaching intersections, according to TF1.

French public agency Cerema, which advises local authorities on transport and infrastructure, has also said that priorité à droite should be kept in place in residential streets wherever possible.

Note that priorité à droite is the default rule at intersections, unless road signs or markings state otherwise.

For the agency, the rule can both keep drivers alert at intersections and make them slow down, but it can also help avoid unnecessary stop-and-go by removing stop signs in less frequented streets.

Journeys are also easier for cyclists, who do not have to stop at every junction.

However, the agency also said that the rule is not suitable for every situation. At intersections with heavy traffic, limited visibility or where public transport needs priority, stop signs can help solve the issue.