transportation

Social media rallies to support man forced to sell his house after SNCF incident

‘The fundraising is a beam of light that could potentially help me get back on my feet’

Arnaud has been forced to sell his home to pay the compensation claim against him

An outpouring of support for a man sentenced to pay €150,000 in compensation following an altercation with an SNCF ticket officer has generated more than €8,000 in crowd-funding so far. 

Arnaud, who chooses to not publish his last name to protect his children’s privacy, is being forced to sell his family home after the huge financial penalty was doled out following the incident on a TGV train five years ago. 

His story, first reported by Le Parisien on November 16, has then been picked up by social media, with many denouncing the severity of the sentence.

“The fundraising is a beam of light that could potentially help me get back on my feet,” he told The Connexion. “I will fight whatever I have because what happened to me is not normal,” he added.

The fall-out from the sentence led to the break-up of his marriage to his wife, an SNCF employee. Money from the crowd-funding will serve to help him rebuild and find a home again, its organisers say.

“I will have to take out loans,” he said. “A chunk of my life is going to be complicated.”

Arnaud, 38, a worker-fitter from Istres (Bouches-du-Rhône), owes nearly €150,000 in civil damages to the SNCF and one of its ticket inspectors after a check that went wrong in April 2021.

Ticket check that went wrong

The check took place on April 15, 2021, as he boarded the first TGV from Aix-en-Provence to Paris to bury his grandmother, who had died of Covid the day before. 

Because his wife was an SNCF employee, he benefited from a ticket 10% of the regular price. However, he had not validated his ticket as the card would not fit the validator and was told by a platform agent to sort it out aboard with the ticket inspector.

During travel, he was woken up by one agent who scolded him.

He protested he had no interest in cheating on a ticket worth a fraction of the fare and refused to hand over his ID, and the inspector walked off with the ticket.

When Arnaud caught up with him and offered to pay, he was told it was too late and that a procedure had been launched.

The train stopped at Mâcon and police called in on the claim that he had assaulted the inspector. He was told he could not get back on the train, meaning he would miss his grandmother’s funeral.

“I went bananas,” he said.

He admits he insulted and made death threats to the inspector but formerly denies any attack.

In October 2021, a criminal court fined him €500 for insults, threats and violence against a transport agent, after his lawyer advised him to acknowledge all the facts.

Civil claim 

Then came the civil claim.

The inspector took 18 months of sick leave, followed by a year at half-time, and listed his losses, which included nearly €30,000 in missed bonuses and €2,500 for weight gain.

An independent expert found the physical impact of the encounter could not have exceeded three weeks.

The SNCF, which acts as its own social insurer, billed him €103,000 for the sick leave, on top of the €45,000 owed to the inspector.

“After the ruling, I started writing to journalists,” he said. “Le Parisien answered.”

The two creditors activated the state-backed guarantee fund, which has paid them and will now pursue Arnaud for life, Le Parisien reported.

“Call it absurd or Kafkaesque,” Daniel Barrionuevo, his lawyer and a criminal barrister at Aix-en-Provence, told The Connexion.

He has written to the justice minister to flag the gap between a €500 criminal fine and a €150,000 civil award, and called on the legislator to rebalance criminal sanction and civil compensation.

The SNCF said Arnaud was condemned “for grave acts of violence, a decision confirmed on appeal”, that the sum was set after a court-ordered medical expertise, and that he could ask to discuss payment by instalments.

“There is the law and there is morality,” Mr Barrionueno said. “We entrust ourselves to the morality of the SNCF for it not to execute the penalty,” he added, pointing to the company's €43billion turnover in 2025.

You can Arnaud via his crowd-funding page.