property

Could France’s rental vote affect old stone homes and outbuildings?

Amendment could allow the re-letting of properties deemed to be energy-inefficient

The amendment could facilitate the rental process for landlords looking to let older properties without needing to finance renovation works
Published Modified

MPs in France have voted to pass an amendment that could scrap the phased ban on letting properties with poor energy efficiency ratings (passoires énergétiques) such as old stone houses and converted outbuildings.

The vote came as part of the debate surrounding the draft bill on housing, and means that energy rating assessments (diagnostic de performance énergétique, DPE) which rate homes from A (best) to G (worst) could be disregarded when it comes to renting.

The amendment was put forward by Frédéric Falcon from the Rassemblement National (RN) and was passed yesterday evening (November 17) by a narrow majority - 108 votes to 102.

“The DPE threatened to simply remove 2.75 million homes from the rental market, particularly in major cities where the market is already under pressure... This is a real victory in terms of giving the housing market some breathing space,” said the RN in a post on social media.



Note that the 2.75 million figure covers all main residences rated F or G in 2027, not just rented homes. 



Under the 2021 loi Climat et résilience (Climate and resilience law), properties rated G were prohibited from being rented to tenants as main residences from 2025, although they could still be let as second homes - while properties rated F could not be rented as main residences from 2028 with E homes due to follow in 2034.

The earlier version of the bill sought to postpone the ban as long as the property owner undertook to carry out renovation works. It also outlined plans for a three-year grace period granted to owners of individual houses and a five-year grace period for co-owned properties such as blocks of flats. 

This provision was intended to enable 650,000 to 700,000 homes to be retained or returned to the rental market by 2028, according to the government. 

However, this most recent amendment could lift the ban altogether, scrapping the 2025, 2028 and 2034 deadlines. 

A formal vote on the whole bill is set for November 24, though this will not yet indicate whether it will be officially adopted. 

What could this mean for homeowners?

If officially adopted, the amendment could facilitate the rental process for landlords looking to let older properties without needing to finance renovation works.

Owners of old rural farmhouses and stone buildings are more likely to see their property receive a lower energy rating, due to out-dated, traditional features providing poor insulation. 

The amendment states that properties being rented would retain an energy criterion, but this is defined by a maximum threshold for energy consumption per m² (the figure has not yet been set). DPE ratings would remain mandatory but would no longer determine whether or not a property can be let.

The statement accompanying the amendment acknowledges this shift in approach, saying that renovations must be “encouraged through incentives, support and innovation rather than by banning letting.”

Note that holiday lets including gîtes, converted barns or outbuildings let to tourists are not impacted by this amendment. These properties are covered by a separate law, the loi Le Meur, under which all tourist lets must be rated between A and D by 2034.

What could this mean for tenants?

The proposed amendment could help to increase the number of properties on the rental market, which has been struggling under a huge increase in demand - including from would-be first-time-buyers unable to purchase a home - and a lack of supply.

However, it received backlash from MPs, particularly those in socialist and ecological parties, with concerns for tenants’ rights and wellbeing.

Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi from La France Insoumise deemed the amendment “a public health issue” and also highlighted the implications of increased energy costs and environmental challenges.

“We experienced a scorching summer: 49% of people in France suffered from the heat in their homes. Furthermore, heat increases the risk of cardiovascular disease,” said Ms Belouassa-Cherifi.

“You are letting landlords off the hook and making tenants pay the price,” she added.