transport
EES errors: What to do if you are wrongly flagged as overstaying
Incorrect details can lead to authorities believing you have overstayed, risking fines and travel bans
News of a British author who was incorrectly flagged as overstaying in Europe through the Entry/Exit System (EES) has raised concerns that others may find themselves in this situation.
The stuttered rollout of the EES, which is still not fully implemented in France and eight other Schengen area countries, has left travellers at risk of falling through the cracks and not having their journeys correctly tracked through the system.
It means that some, such as author Jojo Moyes, may be flagged for spending too much time in the Schengen area, facing possible bans and fines.
If this happens to you, we cover what you should do.
First steps: contact data authorities
If you believe that your exit from a Schengen area country was not correctly recorded, the first thing you should do is contact the relevant authorities in the country you left.
Each Schengen area country has specific authorities tasked with managing EES records and the relevant data protection requirements.
In France there is a data controller and a data protection officer.
The former should be contacted to access or correct personal data in the EES.
You can contact them via letter (Direction générale des étrangers en France, Ministère de l’Intérieur, Place Beauvau, 75008 Paris) or send an email to donnees-personnelles-dgef@interieur.gouv.fr with your request.
You should explain the issue, providing proof of your travel (travel tickets, confirmation, hotel bookings, and for older trips during the phased EES rollout, passport stamps).
They should then be able to contact the relevant technical authorities and have your records updated to show your correct movements.
English language guidance for raising an issue with French authorities is available here.
You can write a letter to the data protection officer (Le Délégué ministériel à la protection des données, Ministère de l’Intérieur, Place Beauvau, 75008 Paris) regarding data protection matters, including if you need support exercising your rights.
However, it does not replace the data controller as the authority that handles these requests.
Finally, there is a supervisory authority, the Commission nationale de l'informatique et des libertés (Cnil, civil liberties commission). You can file a complaint with the Cnil if you believe your data has not been correctly filed, but should not make requests to them about changing EES entries.
For issues regarding an entry or exit outside of France, the relevant national authorities should be contacted – a full list is available through the European Commission website.
Speak to border authorities
However, it is not always clear that the relevant authorities are carrying out the changes when required, leaving some passengers concerned about future travel.
Ms Moyes, for example, spent two weeks trying to resolve the error in her record by contacting authorities including French border officials but made little progress.
There is also the risk that a person may not know their journey has been incorrectly tracked until they are faced with the issue at a Schengen area border.
Fortunately, you can also discuss the issue with border authorities when travelling in and out of the Schengen area.
“If you believe your time spent in the Schengen area has been recorded incorrectly, raise this with border officials and be prepared to provide supporting evidence if requested,” says the UK government on its official travel advice website.
Anecdotal evidence and letters from Connexion readers suggest that in many cases, border officials are willing to update records to show correct entries, if the traveller can prove there has been a mistake.
Travellers can show a list of their entries and exits to all Schengen area locations (written in French or the relevant local language for border guards to read) including details such as flight numbers and times.
Holding onto physical proof such as flight tickets, proof of travel to and from the airport at relevant times, hotel receipts, etc, can therefore be useful.
However, digital alternatives can also be used to strengthen your case.
“Supporting evidence could include return travel tickets, train tickets from the airport or dated receipts showing spending back in the UK,” Luke Petherbridge, Director of Public Affairs at ABTA - The Travel Association, told The Connexion.
“Much of this evidence may already be available on people’s phones, whether through emailed booking confirmations, electronic receipts or transactions shown in their banking app.”