Where are France’s Covid variant hotspots?
The UK variant has spread throughout all the regions of France while the South African and Brazillian variants are concentrated in the east of the country
Covid variants are spreading in France, with the UK variant currently accounting for 36% of positive cases and the South African and Brazilian variants accounting for 5%, Health Minister Olivier Véran said in a press conference on February 18.
Percentages show suspected cases
Health body Santé publique France (SPF) has said that these percentages do not mean that 41% of all Covid cases in France are now variants.
Rather, it indicates the amount of positive tests taken within a fixed period, which have then been checked and are suspected to have the variants.
It said in a statement on February 18: “Nationally, from February 8-14, out of 148,880 positive tests…45% were screened for variants, equivalent to 66,191 tests.
“Out of these screened positive tests, 36% (23,888) are suspected to be UK variants and 5% (3,338) are suspected to be South African or Brazilian variants.”
We look at where the variants are spreading in France.
UK variant spreads throughout France
Data released by SPF from February 17 showed that the UK variant accounted for 30% of positive cases in 40 departments (out of 94 which provided data).
The data shows that the variant has spread throughout all regions of France, with incidences over 50% in 12 departments.
In some areas the rate has climbed even higher – and up to 70% in Dunkirk.
Map showing proportion of suspected UK variant cases throughout France, data from SPF (BFMTV / BFMTV)
UK variant highly transmissible
The UK variant, also called the B117 variant, is known to be highly transmissible, potentially because the virus produces more infectious particles - expelled when people cough, for example - than previous variants.
The B117 strain also replicates twice as fast as the original strain that emerged in Wuhan, making it 40-60% more contagious.
Data – which has not yet been peer reviewed – suggests that the UK variant could be 30% more deadly than previous strains of the virus.
But trials run by major vaccine providers show that the AstraZeneca, Pfizer/BioNTech, and Moderna vaccines all offer high levels of protection against the variant.
South African and Brazilian variants concentrated in east France
SPF found that eight departments had a proportion of over 10% of the South African and Brazilian variants.
But one department had notably higher rates – in Moselle the proportion of the variants was at 40%, according to data from February 17.
Map showing proportion of suspected South African and Brazilian variant cases throughout France, data from SPF (BFMTV / BFMTV)
South African variant spreads rapidly
The South African variant, also called 501Y.V2 or B1351, emerged in October 2020.
There is no indication that this variant causes more serious illnesses than previous strains, but it does spread rapidly, and studies have suggested that the variant may be able to escape Covid antibodies, making it more resistant to some vaccines.
South Africa has suspended use of the Oxford/Aztra-Zeneca vaccine after a study found it offered “limited” protection of only 22% against local variants of the virus.
But Pfizer and Moderna trials showed that the two vaccines offered immunity at a level considered to be protective against the variant.
Fears over Brazilian variant reinfection
A statement from the US Centre for Disease Control and Prevention has suggested that the Brazilian variant may have increased capacity to reinfect individuals who have already had the Covid virus, and that it may be able to evade parts of the immune system.
But there is, so far, no evidence to suggest that vaccines will not be effective against this variant.