top cx logo
cx logo
Explorearrow down
search icon
arrow down

The circus has come to town, and it’s here to stay

WHETHER it be the traditional “big top” variety run by families across generations, small itinerant shows travelling from village to village, or cutting-edge presentations, the circus is hugely popular in France, surpassing the theatre as a preferred form of entertainment. They are bigger than ever in France. Jane Hanks finds out why

It also has a social role, with hospital clowns now classed as a profession and circus schools bringing life to deprived areas. And the newer contemporary style of circus was pioneered in France.

The circus in France is supported by a government-funded body, HorsLesMurs, founded in 1993, which discovered in a recent survey that 78% of people over 15 had been to le cirque at least once, compared to 58% for the theatre, making the circus the most popular form of live show.

English origins of French circus

But it was an Englishman who first introduced the circus to France. Philip Astley, a cavalry officer born in Newcastle-Under-Lyme, is seen as the founder of traditional circus. In the 1770s, he put on a largely horse-based show in his riding school in London. By chance he rode in a circle rather than a straight line and later added a clown to amuse his spectators.

He erected a covered building with a circular stage 13m in diameter – which has been the model for the circus ring ever since – and took his idea to Paris where he built the Amphithéâtre Anglais, the first purpose-built circus in France. The building, which no longer exists, was then leased to Antonio Franconi, an Italian equestrian who helped introduce Astley’s idea to France. Franconi later moved premises and handed his business down to his two sons.

There are now several big family circuses in France including Cirque Medrano, Stephan Zavatta and Arlette Gruss. One of the biggest is the Cirque Pinder, which also has its origins in the UK.

In the 19th century, William Pinder owned a travelling theatre, which he transformed into a circus in Hartlepool after he came into possession of a huge sail from a warship which he used for his big top, calling it the Britania.

In 1868, he took his show to France and eventually settled there in 1904.

Welcome to 'Pinderland'

Since then, the show has survived two world wars and continues to tour the country to this day. Its present owner, Gilbert Edelstein, is passionate about his circus and plans to open Pinderland, a circus park in 2016 at Perthes-en-Gâtinais, near Melun in Seine-et-Marne.

It will have a 1,500-seat capacity permanent big top – with shows on Wednesdays, Saturdays and Sundays – a circus school, two museums and a large collection of animals.

Mr Edelstein’s dream is to have sheep, donkeys, deer and horses living in semi-freedom, traditional circus animals in enclosures and elephant and camel rides through the park for the public.

The tours round the country will continue. Every year there are more than 650 shows put on in more than 100 towns, with 120 people and 50 animals involved. Prices range from €7 to €45.

“Traditional circus is still as popular as it has ever been,” said Mr Edelstein.

“It attracts an audience of 14 million every year, far more than the modern, contemporary circus, and despite the cinema, television and computers people love to see live exploits which give you the shivers.

“It is a huge adventure and there is such a variety of acts. It’s for real and makes everyone happy. I think there is a big future still ahead of us. And in my circus my son and daughter are there to carry it on for me.”

What makes a traditional circus?

How does he describe traditional circus? “The circus is acrobats, clowns, magic brought together by a unity of colour. And for me no circus is complete without the animals. It is what attracts people. I am looking forward to showing an even greater public these animals at Pinderland.”

In the 2015 show there are 11 acts – of which three are with animals. The first, Les Animaux Exotiques, showcases camels, horses, donkeys, zebras and llamas, the second features elephants and the third has Mr Edelstein’s son, Frédéric, performing with a dozen white lions (he has presented his act a record 10,000 times).

Animal rights

The use of animals brings Pinder into conflict with a growing number of campaigners who want to see circus animals banned, which is already the case in some countries.

In September, the Netherlands passed a law banning most mammals, such as elephants, tigers and lions from circuses - however there is a list of 'domesticated' animals which can appear including dogs, horses and camels. Other European countries which ban all or certain animals include Austria, Belgium, Greece and Finland, and many have local bans such as in Spain and the UK.

In France there are laws governing the conditions in which circus animals are kept. Hippopotami must have access to a large pool, the sizes of cages are regulated and the animals have to be in good health to perform.

However, Code Animal, an animal welfare association in France linked with the European umbrella organisation Endcap, sees these measures as inadequate.

It has joined in a Europewide petition to promote the total ban of animals in circuses. The move is largely supported by animal welfare groups, including the SPA in France.

“Animals shouldn’t be in circuses because they cannot live a natural life in the conditions they would find in the wild,” said Code Animal president and founder Franck Schrafstetter.

“Elephants for example usually walk 17km a day and spend on average an hour in the water and live in a matriarchal society. Even if a circus complies with the rules, as Pinder does, we still believe that circus life is not suitable, whether or not the animals were born in captivity or found in the wild.

“Studies have shown that these animals develop behavioural features, such as displacing their weight from foot to foot, which is proof of chronic stress. We believe many circuses mistreat their animals.”

Mr Schrafstetter says that if people want to see an end to circus animals they should sign the Code Animal petition and avoid such shows – or if they do go send photographs of any proof of badly treated animals.

But Mr Edelstein, who is also the president of the Syndicat National du Cirque grouping the biggest circuses, says animals are essential: “Nine out of 10 phone calls from the public are asking whether there are animals in the show. I don’t understand why there is this movement against us. Our animals are treated very well.”

France blazing a trail with the art form the British invented

WHILE the roots of traditional circus may have come from the UK, it is accepted that France has led the way forward for the whole world in the development of contemporary circus.

There is now a national training school with free tuition for artists, funded by the Ministry of Culture. The Connexion spoke to the head of the Centre National des Arts du Cirque (CNAC), former trapeze artist Gérard Fasoli:

What is the difference between traditional and contemporary circus?

Traditional circus is a series of different acts linked together by a ringmaster and is purely entertainment. Contemporary circus has no animals and produces a global show where the performers work together rather than in separate acts. We see it more as an art form. The audiences are different with perhaps a more intellectual public for contemporary circus.

Are the two types of circus compatible?

There is room for both. I am 72 now and my background is in the big top. I have a great love for traditional circus, and though I campaigned to bring the more modern circus to the forefront I know we owe a lot to the older style and I do emphasise its strengths to our students.

Why has France led the way in contemporary circus?

We owe a lot of its success to the Minister of Culture in the early 1980s, Jack Lang, who saw its potential and gave it the backing we needed. Up until then circus came under the Ministry of Agriculture because of the animals. Now we are very well supported by the government who give 90% of funding to our school. It is small with about 18 pupils every year who are chosen out of 200 hopefuls.

They learn many skills but usually have a speciality and if they are good they will have no problem finding work afterwards. They may go into a small company, form their own, join a traditional circus or go into cabaret.

At present the circus is healthy in France and the rest of Europe – it is enjoying a period of expansion.

Is the circus regarded as an art form in France?

Yes, I think we can now join the ranks of our older siblings, theatre and dance. We even have a researcher who is creating notation for circus moves, like the one which exists for dance, so that we can have our own written language.

At present whole routines have to be explained orally but this will mean we can hand on different acts to other artists much more easily.

Resident or second-home owner in France?
Benefit from our daily digest of headlines and how-to's to help you make the most of life in France
By joining the newsletter, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy
See more popular articles
The Connexion Help Guides
featured helpguide
Income Tax in France 2023 (for 2022 income)*
Featured Help Guide
- Primarily aimed at Britons, covers pensions, rent, ISAs, shares, savings and interest - but also contains significant general information pertinent to readers of other nationalities - Overview of online declarations + step-by-step guide to the French printed forms - Includes updates given automatically after this year's site opened
Get news, views and information from France