news
A10 martyr cold case: Parents jailed 39 years after girl’s death
Four-year-old Inass Touloub’s body was found beside the motorway in 1987
The parents of a four-year-old girl murdered and left by the side of a French motorway nearly 40 years ago have received lengthy prison sentences relating to her death.
Her mother, Halima El Bakhti, 72, was sentenced to 20 years in prison for acts of torture and barbarity resulting in the child’s death, and her father, Ahmed Touloub, 74, was sentenced to 15 years for complicity in this crime.
Both were taken immediately into custody following the verdict.
Jurors and court officials spent seven hours deliberating the verdict before coming to their decision at a trial in Blois (Loir-et-Cher) that garnered widespread media attention.
The court said that the “exceptional gravity of the acts, committed within the privacy of the family home by those who ought to have been the primary guarantors,” led to the final decision.
The body of Inass Touloub was found by motorway maintenance workers beside the A10 in Suèvres, in Loir-et-Cher, in 1987, heavily disfigured.
Her death remained a mystery for 30 years, becoming one of France’s most infamous cold cases, before her brother was involved in an altercation at a restaurant and provided a DNA test which was a match to Inass.
Authorities tracked down her parents, who went on trial at the start of this month.
Torture and barbarity
The court concluded that the mother had “deliberately committed acts of torture and barbarity,” including those that resulted in Inass’ death.
“The abuse inflicted demonstrated that Inass was no longer viewed as a child, but rather as a vessel for maternal cruelty.”
However, a legal assessment by the court also declared that her decision-making capacity was impaired at the time of Inass’s death.
She had suffered from several mental crises over her life, including bouts of intense depression – with her other children claiming she used to smash her head against the wall and throw herself to the floor – two suicide attempts, and what her lawyer said would now be considered post-partum depression.
This limited the maximum sentence she could receive to 20 years – although this was still handed down to her.
“To put it mildly, what she says is impossible to listen to. One has no desire to hear it. Her account is incomplete, at times confused, and often shocking,” said her defence lawyer Camille Radot in his concluding remarks.
“Halima El Bakhti’s confessions are to be found in her silences.”
Lawyer plea to reject an ‘act of vengeance’
However, the lawyer pointed to the childhood of Mrs El Bakhti, which likely included acts of violence from her own mother.
Cigarette burns and scars are still visible on her body from her own childhood, he said, and her own experiences as a child fed into her relationship with her daughter.
She did not want to leave her child alone with her mother, but was forced to do so soon after Inass’ birth in 1983, when her husband asked her to come to France to help him run a grocery store he had opened.
When she returned to collect Inass in 1984, “it was inevitable that the reunion would go poorly.”
Inass’ difficulty in adapting to life in France, coupled with the psychological trauma from her mother, led to some of the abuse.
“It is not unreasonable to suggest that when this little girl arrives; raised by a mother who herself tortured [the defendant during her own childhood], everything just explodes,” he added.
He also remarked on her difficult circumstances at home, including several pregnancies close together.
“She was living in the country illegally; she never left her home, had no friends, and no neighbours to rely on. She had no one [and] six children to look after.”
The lawyer urged the court not to hand down a life sentence, even though “that is what people on the outside are demanding.”
Such a sentence “could only be interpreted as an act of vengeance… and vengeance must not be your guiding principle,” he added.
‘Remaining silent does not make someone an accomplice’
Despite her father not being charged for torturing the child himself, the court said he “could not have been unaware of the abuse suffered” by his daughter and failed to "ensure his daughter’s health and protection.”
However, his lawyer Yasmina Belmokhtar said the court had mischarged him.
“Remaining silent does not make one an accomplice,” she said.
There was no intent from the father to harm his daughter and he “never wished to participate, directly or indirectly, in the death of his little girl.”
“You are being asked to twist the law, at any cost, to force his behaviour into a framework for prosecution.”
She pointed to accounts by several of the couple’s children that Mr Touloub was terrified of his wife and also a recipient of her violence, and was too scared to speak up to her.
“Let’s imagine a woman suffering violence at the hands of her spouse; someone who doesn't leave and doesn't report the abuse. Would that shock us? [there is a] deeply ingrained notion in our society that a man should not be afraid of his wife.”
Another defence lawyer for Mr Touloub highlighted the generational differences.
“He gets up at 05:00 and returns home exhausted from his day. To him, being a good father means working. Because, in his generation, within that community, if you bring home money, your children can go to school, get an education, and pursue a trade. That is what a father’s role is to them. It goes no further than that,” said Frank Berton.
Mr Touloub’s lawyers say they intend to appeal the decision.