French supermarket Casino to remove E171 from shelves

Casino has become the first supermarket group in France to announce a total removal of the additive

Supermarket group Casino is to remove the additive titanium dioxide, or E171, from all of its products by the end of this year.

E171 is a whitening additive often used in toothpaste and other cosmetics, food products, and medicines. The additive, which is still legal to use, has been linked to cancer.

In a 2017 study, research group L'Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA) called for manufacturers to be alert to the risks.

Casino has now become the first supermarket to announce a zero-use policy from the end of 2018.

This move may cause a change to the look and feel of some products, and some may no longer be available.

Claire Luquet, director of Casino, said: “For example, in a toothpaste for children, the white colour was not good [without E171], so we decided to no longer make the paste with white and blue stripes, and just have an entirely blue toothpaste.”

She continued: “We had a biscuit that had a soft milk filling, but the colour was not attractive [without E171]. So we made the choice to simply remove the product [from our shelves].”

Many cosmetics use E171 for whitening purposes (Pixabay / CC0 Creative Commons)

Casino is not the only brand to make the change.

Earlier this year, sweet manufacturers joined together to sign a charter that pledged to remove E171 from their products by 2021.

The government has also pledged to remove the additive from circulation. In May, Secretary of State, Brune Poirson, announced that the use of titanium dioxide nanoparticles would be outlawed “before the end of the year”.

But the confectionery brand Lutti - the second largest in France - acknowledged that this could cost companies dear.

Sébastien Berghe, owner of Lutti, explained that “[E171] is not an expensive product”, and that removing it completely would entail “higher costs” for his business.

He said: “At Lutti, this has cost several hundred thousand euros in investment over two years. There are also changes in recipes, tools, and packaging. Our sweets will be more expensive.”

But Mr Berghe added: “We do not wait for lawmakers to take decisions on our recipes. [We are] more likely to listen to the scientific community, to consumers, or to NGOs. Often, laws change soon after.”

Stay informed:
Sign up to our free weekly e-newsletter
Subscribe to access all our online articles and receive our printed monthly newspaper The Connexion at your home. News analysis, features and practical help for English-speakers in France

More articles from French news
More articles from Connexion France
Other articles that may interest you